How Can I File A Post-Service Standard Appeal With My Medicare Advantage Plan?If you have a Medicare Advantage Plan and were denied coverage for a health service or item that you have already received, you may choose to appeal to ask your plan to reconsider its decision. Follow the steps below if you think the denied health service or item should be covered by your plan.

  1. You should receive a written notice from your plan stating that it is not covering your health service or item. This can either be an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or a notice titled Notice of Denial of Payment. The notice should explain what you need to do to appeal and the reason your care is not being covered.
    1. Remember, an EOB is not a bill. If your EOB states that a service was not paid for by your plan, call your plan to ask why. It may be a billing or coding error. If it is a denial, you should begin your appeal.
  2. Start your appeal by following the instructions on the notice you received from your plan. Make sure to file your appeal within 60 days of the date on the notice. You will most likely need to send a letter to the plan explaining why you needed the service you received. You may also want to ask your doctor to write a letter or support, explaining why you need care and addressing the plan’s concerns. Your plan should make a decision within 60 days.
    1. If you have a good reason for missing your appeal deadline, you may be eligible for a good cause extension (see When and How Should I Request a Good Cause Extension?).
  3. If your appeal is successful, your service or item will be covered. If your appeal is denied, you should receive a written denial notice. Your plan should automatically forward your appeal to the next level, the Independent Review Entity (IRE). The IRE should make a decision within 60 days of the date on your plan denial notice.
    1. If your plan misses the 60-day decision deadline, your appeal will be considered denied, and your plan should automatically forward your appeal to the IRE.
  4. If your appeal to the IRE is successful, your service or item will be covered. If your IRE appeal is denied and your care is worth at least $160 in 2019, you can choose to appeal to the OMHA level. You must file your OMHA level appeal within 60 days of the date on your IRE denial letter. If you decide to appeal to the OMHA level, you may want to contact a lawyer or legal services organization to help you with this or later steps in your appeal—but this is not required.
  5. If your appeal to the OMHA level is successful, your service or item will be covered. If your appeal is denied and your health service or item is worth at least $160 in 2019, you can appeal to the Council within 60 days of the date on your OMHA level denial letter. There is no timeframe for the Council to make a decision about your appeal.
  6. If your appeal to the Council is successful, your care will be covered. If your appeal is denied and your health service or item is worth at least $1,630 in 2019, you can appeal to the Federal District Court within 60 days of the date on your Council denial letter. There is no timeframe for the Federal District Court to make a decision about your appeal.

Read Next: What are Some Tips for Making a Strong Appeal?
Learn About: When and How Should I Request a Good Cause Extension?
Return to: Medicare In-Depth

This content was created and copyrighted by the Medicare Rights Center ©2019. Medicare Rights Center is a national, nonprofit consumer service organization that works to ensure access to affordable health care for older adults and people with disabilities. These materials are presented here with support from YourMedicare.com and may not be distributed, modified or edited without Medicare Rights’ consent.

YourMedicare.com takes pride in providing you as much information as possible concerning your Medicare options, but only a health insurance broker licensed to sell Medicare can help you compare your plan options from various insurance companies. When you’re ready, we recommend you discuss your needs with a YourMedicare.com Licensed Sales Agent.